CAT 2023 Slot 1 VARC Question 9

Multiple choice (+3 / −1) · Reading Comprehension · Literature · Try it, then check the answer and solution below.

CAT 2023 Slot 1VARCReading Comprehension • LiteratureModerate
Reading Comprehension Passage•~509 words
For early postcolonial literature, the world of the novel was often the nation. Postcolonial novels were usually concerned with national questions. Sometimes the whole story of the novel was taken as an allegory of the nation, whether India or Tanzania. This was important for supporting anti-colonial nationalism, but could also be limiting - land-focused and inward- looking.
My new book "Writing Ocean Worlds" explores another kind of world of the novel: not the village or nation, but the Indian Ocean world. The book describes a set of novels in which the Indian Ocean is at the centre of the story. It focuses on the novelists Amitav Ghosh, Abdulrazak Gurnah, Lindsey Collen and Joseph Conrad who have centred the Indian Ocean world in the majority of their novels. Their work reveals a world that is outward-looking -full of movement, border-crossing and south-south interconnection. They are all very different – from colonially inclined (Conrad) to radically anti-capitalist (Collen), but together draw on and shape a wider sense of Indian Ocean space through themes, images, metaphors and language. This has the effect of remapping the world in the reader's mind, as centred in the interconnected global south.
The Indian Ocean world is a term used to describe the very long-lasting connections among the coasts of East Africa, the Arab coasts, and South and East Asia. These connections were made possible by the geography of the Indian Ocean. For much of history, travel by sea was much easier than by land, which meant that port cities very far apart were often more easily connected to each other than to much closer inland cities. Historical and archaeological evidence suggests that what we now call globalisation first appeared in the Indian Ocean.
This is the interconnected oceanic world referenced and produced by the novels in my book. For their part Ghosh, Gurnah, Collen and even Conrad reference a different set of histories and geographies than the ones most commonly found in fiction in English. Those commonly found ones are mostly centred in Europe or the US, assume a background of Christianity and whiteness, and mention places like Paris and New York. The novels in my book highlight instead a largely Islamic space, feature characters of colour and centralise the ports of Malindi, Mombasa, Aden, Java and Bombay.
It is a densely imagined, richly sensory image of a southern cosmopolitan culture which provides for an enlarged sense of place in the world. This remapping is particularly powerful for the representation of Africa. In the fiction, sailors and travellers are not all European. African, as well as Indian and Arab characters, are traders, nakhodas (dhow ship captains), runaways, villains, missionaries and activists. This does not mean that Indian Ocean Africa is romanticised. Migration is often a matter of force; travel is portrayed as abandonment rather than adventure, freedoms are kept from women and slavery is rife. What it does mean is that the African part of the Indian Ocean world plays an active role in its long, rich history and therefore in that of the wider world.
All of the following statements, if true, would weaken the passage's claim about the relationship between mainstream English-language fiction and Indian Ocean novels EXCEPT:
Answer and solution

Answer:

C
most mainstream English-language novels have historically privileged the Christian, white, male experience of travel and
adventure.

Step-by-Step Explanation and Answer:
1
Passage Context & Central Idea:
The passage discusses how postcolonial literature often focuses on national narratives, but the author's new book shifts the focus to the Indian Ocean world. This new perspective highlights the interconnectedness and diversity of cultures in the Indian Ocean, contrasting it with mainstream English-language fiction, which typically centers on European or American settings with a Christian and white cultural backdrop.
2
Question Stem Analysis:
The question asks which statement, if true, would NOT weaken the passage's argument about the distinction between mainstream English fiction and Indian Ocean novels. Essentially, we need to identify the option that supports the passage's claim rather than undermining it.
3
Option-by-Option Elimination:
Option A: If the depiction of Africa in Indian Ocean novels is driven by postcolonial nostalgia for an idyllic past, this would imply a romanticized view, potentially weakening the argument that these novels provide a realistic and enriched portrayal of Africa's role.
Option B: If the depiction is driven by Orientalist stereotypes, this would directly weaken the argument by suggesting harmful and inaccurate portrayals.
Option C: This statement supports the passage's claim by highlighting that mainstream English novels have historically privileged the Christian, white, male experience, thereby underscoring the contrast with Indian Ocean novels.
Option D: If few mainstream novels are set in American or European centers, this might not directly weaken the argument, as the passage focuses more on thematic content than geographical setting.
4
Final Answer Confirmation:
The correct answer is Option C, as it aligns with and supports the passage's argument by emphasizing the contrast between mainstream English fiction and the Indian Ocean novels.
Correct Answer: C

Keep going

Related Literature questions