Q5. Games & Tournaments
MCQ · +3 / −1
What were the bids by Arun, Bankim, Charu and Dipak, respectively in the first round?
- A) Lo, Lo, Lo, Hi
- B) Hi, Lo, Lo, Hi
- C) Hi, Hi, Lo, Lo
- D) Hi, Lo, Lo, Lo
Correct Answer
B) Hi, Lo, Lo, Hi
Step-by-step solution
📌 Core Concept
A round's payoff depends only on the number of Hi bids. So each option for round 1 can be tested against Dipak's clue (fact 3) and the score totals.
🔢 Step-by-Step Solution
1
Payoffs per player: 4 Hi gives -1 each; 3 Hi gives +1 to Hi and -3 to Lo; 2 Hi gives +2 to Hi and -2 to Lo; 1 Hi gives +3 to Hi and -1 to Lo; 0 Hi gives +1 each. A player's round score is never 0.
2
Option A has Dipak as the only Hi bidder. Arun then scores -1 in round 1, so he needs 7 from rounds 2 and 3 to reach 6. The maximum is , so A fails.
3
Option C gives Dipak -2 in round 1. Fact 3 needs , so , and then , which is impossible. C fails.
4
Option D gives Dipak -1 in round 1. Fact 3 then forces and . His total would be , not the 2 given in fact 1. D fails.
5
Option B has Arun and Dipak bidding Hi against two Lo bids, so the Hi players get +2 and the Lo players get -2. After round 1 the scores are Arun 2, Bankim -2, Charu -2, Dipak 2. Dipak then needs 0 over rounds 2 and 3, with . This gives and , which works and is consistent with the rest of the data.
Why Not the Others
A: Arun cannot reach 6 after three rounds.
C: Dipak's clue 3 cannot be satisfied.
D: Dipak's three-round total comes to -6, not 2.
Correct Answer: B