CAT 2023 Slot 2 QA Question 8

Multiple choice (+3 / −1) · Arithmetic · Time & Work · Try it, then check the answer and solution below.

Pipes AA and CC are fill pipes while Pipe BB is a drain pipe of a tank. Pipe BB empties the full tank in one hour less than the time taken by Pipe AA to fill the empty tank. When pipes A,BA , B and CC are turned on together, the empty tank is filled in two hours. If pipes BB and CC are turned on together when the tank is empty and Pipe BB is turned off after one hour, then Pipe CC takes another one hour and 15 minutes to fill the remaining tank. If Pipe AA can fill the empty tank in less than five hours, then the time taken, in minutes, by Pipe CC to fill the empty tank is
Answer and solution

Answer: D) 9090

First, let's parse the question. There are three pipes: A and C are fill pipes, and B is a drain pipe. So, A and C add water to the tank, while B removes it. The question gives me some relationships between their rates and asks for the time Pipe C takes to fill the tank alone.
Let me note down the key points:
1
Pipe B empties the tank in one hour less than Pipe A takes to fill it. So, if A takes 'a' hours, B takes 'a - 1' hours to empty.
2
When A, B, and C are all open together, the tank fills in 2 hours.
3
When only B and C are open, and after one hour B is turned off, C takes another 1 hour and 15 minutes (which is 1.25 hours) to finish filling the tank.
4
Pipe A fills the tank in less than five hours, so 'a' is less than 5.
We need to find the time Pipe C takes to fill the tank alone, which I'll denote as 'c' hours.
Alright, let's assign variables to the rates. Since rates are usually reciprocal of time, I'll let:
Rate of A = 1/a (tank per hour)
Rate of B = 1/(a - 1) (tank per hour, but since it's draining, it's negative)
Rate of C = 1/c (tank per hour)
Now, let's translate the given information into equations.
First scenario: A, B, and C together fill the tank in 2 hours. So, their combined rate is 1/2 tank per hour.
So, equation 1: (1/a) + (1/c) - (1/(a - 1)) = 1/2
Second scenario: B and C are open for one hour, then B is turned off, and C takes another 1.25 hours. So, in the first hour, B and C together fill some part, and then C fills the rest.
Compute how much is filled in the first hour. The combined rate of B and C is (1/c) - (1/(a - 1)). So, in one hour, they fill (1/c - 1/(a - 1)) tanks.
Then, the remaining part is filled by C alone in 1.25 hours. So, the remaining part is 1.25 * (1/c).
So, total filled is:
(1/c - 1/(a - 1)) + 1.25*(1/c) = 1
Let me write that as equation 2:
(1/c - 1/(a - 1)) + (5/4)*(1/c) = 1
Simplify equation 2:
Combine the terms with 1/c:
(1 + 5/4)/c - 1/(a - 1) = 1
Which is (9/4)/c - 1/(a - 1) = 1
So, equation 2 becomes: 9/(4c) - 1/(a - 1) = 1
Now, I have two equations:
1
(1/a) + (1/c) - (1/(a - 1)) = 1/2
2
9/(4c) - 1/(a - 1) = 1
Hmm, so I can maybe solve these two equations for a and c.
Let equation 1 as:
1/a + 1/c - 1/(a - 1) = 1/2
And equation 2 as:
9/(4c) - 1/(a - 1) = 1
Let me try to express 1/(a - 1) from equation 2.
From equation 2:
9/(4c) - 1/(a - 1) = 1
So, rearranged:
-1/(a - 1) = 1 - 9/(4c)
Multiply both sides by -1:
1/(a - 1) = -1 + 9/(4c)
So, 1/(a - 1) = (9/(4c)) - 1
Now, plug this into equation 1.
Equation 1:
1/a + 1/c - [ (9/(4c)) - 1 ] = 1/2
Simplify inside the brackets:
1/a + 1/c - 9/(4c) + 1 = 1/2
Combine like terms:
1/a + (1/c - 9/(4c)) + 1 = 1/2
Compute 1/c - 9/(4c):
(4/4c - 9/4c) = (-5)/(4c)
So, equation becomes:
1/a - 5/(4c) + 1 = 1/2
Subtract 1 from both sides:
1/a - 5/(4c) = -1/2
So, 1/a - 5/(4c) = -1/2
Let me write this as:
1/a = 5/(4c) - 1/2
Hmm, so now I have expressions for 1/(a - 1) and 1/a in terms of c.
if I can express a in terms of c or vice versa.
From equation 2, we had:
1/(a - 1) = 9/(4c) - 1
Let me write that as:
1/(a - 1) = (9 - 4c)/(4c)
So, a - 1 = 4c / (9 - 4c)
Similarly, from equation 1, we have:
1/a = 5/(4c) - 1/2
Compute 5/(4c) - 1/2:
= (5 - 2c)/(4c)
So, 1/a = (5 - 2c)/(4c)
Therefore, a = 4c / (5 - 2c)
So now, I have expressions for a and a - 1 in terms of c.
From above:
a = 4c / (5 - 2c)
And a - 1 = 4c / (9 - 4c)
So, since a - 1 = 4c / (9 - 4c), and a = 4c / (5 - 2c), we can write:
a - 1 = 4c / (9 - 4c)
But a is 4c / (5 - 2c), so:
4c / (5 - 2c) - 1 = 4c / (9 - 4c)
Let me

Keep going

Related Time & Work questions